USB hard drive causing sound problems

Posted: 01-23-2004, 06:49 PM
I recently bought a USB external hard drive and notice that
whenever I have it turned on it causes a cracking sound
when I play music (or generate sound, eg with text to
speech programs). Kind of like suddenly the music is being
played off an old record. Sure enough, when I turn the
drive off at the mains (or disconnect it), sound returns to
normal with no cracking. Some points to note are:

- This only happens with my cheap Creative Soundblaster PCI
card, when I use my rubbish onboard sound, no cracking
happens (I have no other PCI sound cards to test, but I
would assume that the problem is not specific to my card,
just the fact that it's a PCI card).

- The problem does not occur when I use Linux (thus I'm
guessing it's some problem in Windows XP).

- I have the latest drivers for my motherboard, sound card
and Windows updates.

- I've tried moving my sound card to a different PCI slot,
but that didn't help.

- My external hard drive is fine, nothing wrong with it.

I'm absolutely stumped why this is happening - I have other
USB devices and they don't cause a problem (so I'm guessing
it's only hard drives and similar stuff which is constantly
accessed).

Any help is appreciated.

Thanks
Aaron.

My Computer:
Athlon XP 2400
ASRock Motherboard (KV7 Something off the top of my head)
Creative Soundblaster standard sound card
2 x internal hard drives (Windows XP Home / SuSE 9)
Cd writer, DVD drive
NVIDIA Geforce 2 64MB MX graphics
....etc.

USB hard drive causing sound problems


Reply With Quote

Responses to "USB hard drive causing sound problems"

Yves Leclerc
Guest
Posts: n/a
 
Re: USB hard drive causing sound problems
Posted: 01-23-2004, 08:13 PM
Sounds like the PCI slot and the USB ports are "sharing" the IRQ lines. Try
to install the Sound Blaster in a different slot.

Y.

"Scully" <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:35f501c3e1ea$05969f60$a601280a@phx.gbl...
> I recently bought a USB external hard drive and notice that
> whenever I have it turned on it causes a cracking sound
> when I play music (or generate sound, eg with text to
> speech programs). Kind of like suddenly the music is being
> played off an old record. Sure enough, when I turn the
> drive off at the mains (or disconnect it), sound returns to
> normal with no cracking. Some points to note are:
>
> - This only happens with my cheap Creative Soundblaster PCI
> card, when I use my rubbish onboard sound, no cracking
> happens (I have no other PCI sound cards to test, but I
> would assume that the problem is not specific to my card,
> just the fact that it's a PCI card).
>
> - The problem does not occur when I use Linux (thus I'm
> guessing it's some problem in Windows XP).
>
> - I have the latest drivers for my motherboard, sound card
> and Windows updates.
>
> - I've tried moving my sound card to a different PCI slot,
> but that didn't help.
>
> - My external hard drive is fine, nothing wrong with it.
>
> I'm absolutely stumped why this is happening - I have other
> USB devices and they don't cause a problem (so I'm guessing
> it's only hard drives and similar stuff which is constantly
> accessed).
>
> Any help is appreciated.
>
> Thanks
> Aaron.
>
> My Computer:
> Athlon XP 2400
> ASRock Motherboard (KV7 Something off the top of my head)
> Creative Soundblaster standard sound card
> 2 x internal hard drives (Windows XP Home / SuSE 9)
> Cd writer, DVD drive
> NVIDIA Geforce 2 64MB MX graphics
> ...etc.
>

Reply With Quote
Guest
Posts: n/a
 
Re: USB hard drive causing sound problems
Posted: 01-23-2004, 08:32 PM
I've tried - doesn't work.

>-----Original Message-----
>Sounds like the PCI slot and the USB ports are "sharing"
the IRQ lines. Try
>to install the Sound Blaster in a different slot.
>
>Y.
>
>"Scully" <anonymous@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in
message
>news:35f501c3e1ea$05969f60$a601280a@phx.gbl...
>> I recently bought a USB external hard drive and notice
that
>> whenever I have it turned on it causes a cracking sound
>> when I play music (or generate sound, eg with text to
>> speech programs). Kind of like suddenly the music is
being
>> played off an old record. Sure enough, when I turn the
>> drive off at the mains (or disconnect it), sound returns
to
>> normal with no cracking. Some points to note are:
>>
>> - This only happens with my cheap Creative Soundblaster
PCI
>> card, when I use my rubbish onboard sound, no cracking
>> happens (I have no other PCI sound cards to test, but I
>> would assume that the problem is not specific to my
card,
>> just the fact that it's a PCI card).
>>
>> - The problem does not occur when I use Linux (thus I'm
>> guessing it's some problem in Windows XP).
>>
>> - I have the latest drivers for my motherboard, sound
card
>> and Windows updates.
>>
>> - I've tried moving my sound card to a different PCI
slot,
>> but that didn't help.
>>
>> - My external hard drive is fine, nothing wrong with it.
>>
>> I'm absolutely stumped why this is happening - I have
other
>> USB devices and they don't cause a problem (so I'm
guessing
>> it's only hard drives and similar stuff which is
constantly
>> accessed).
>>
>> Any help is appreciated.
>>
>> Thanks
>> Aaron.
>>
>> My Computer:
>> Athlon XP 2400
>> ASRock Motherboard (KV7 Something off the top of my
head)
>> Creative Soundblaster standard sound card
>> 2 x internal hard drives (Windows XP Home / SuSE 9)
>> Cd writer, DVD drive
>> NVIDIA Geforce 2 64MB MX graphics
>> ...etc.
>>
>
>
>.
>
Reply With Quote
Guest
Posts: n/a
 
USB hard drive causing sound problems
Posted: 01-23-2004, 08:36 PM
Have you checked your settings in your bios? They should
be PNP if you are using a Microsoft Windows-based o/s
>-----Original Message-----
>I recently bought a USB external hard drive and notice
that
>whenever I have it turned on it causes a cracking sound
>when I play music (or generate sound, eg with text to
>speech programs). Kind of like suddenly the music is
being
>played off an old record. Sure enough, when I turn the
>drive off at the mains (or disconnect it), sound returns
to
>normal with no cracking. Some points to note are:
>
>- This only happens with my cheap Creative Soundblaster
PCI
>card, when I use my rubbish onboard sound, no cracking
>happens (I have no other PCI sound cards to test, but I
>would assume that the problem is not specific to my
card,
>just the fact that it's a PCI card).
>
>- The problem does not occur when I use Linux (thus I'm
>guessing it's some problem in Windows XP).
>
>- I have the latest drivers for my motherboard, sound
card
>and Windows updates.
>
>- I've tried moving my sound card to a different PCI
slot,
>but that didn't help.
>
>- My external hard drive is fine, nothing wrong with it.
>
>I'm absolutely stumped why this is happening - I have
other
>USB devices and they don't cause a problem (so I'm
guessing
>it's only hard drives and similar stuff which is
constantly
>accessed).
>
>Any help is appreciated.
>
>Thanks
>Aaron.
>
>My Computer:
>Athlon XP 2400
>ASRock Motherboard (KV7 Something off the top of my head)
>Creative Soundblaster standard sound card
>2 x internal hard drives (Windows XP Home / SuSE 9)
>Cd writer, DVD drive
>NVIDIA Geforce 2 64MB MX graphics
>....etc.
>
>.
>
Reply With Quote
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Reply


Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On
Forum Jump


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
sound device and hard drive bharath Windows Vista Hardware & Devices 0 10-10-2007 12:33 PM
Missing drive letter causing big Windows problems badun Windows Vista Hardware & Devices 0 08-09-2007 02:14 PM
Why no sound after I formatted my hard drive. Alonso Windows XP Music 1 02-03-2004 06:41 AM
conflict with sound after hard drive partition Gez Windows XP Hardware 1 11-07-2003 06:17 PM
Hard Drive causing Event Viewer 11 Errors Debby J Windows XP Hardware 1 10-18-2003 08:44 PM